Our Top Priority BOOK A FREE CONSULTATION
Understanding the Difference Between SSI and SSDI: Which One Is Right for You?
Often, individuals feel uncertain about whether to apply for Supplemental Security Income (SSI) or Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI). Both programs are administered by the Social Security Administration (SSA) but have unique eligibility requirements and benefits.
The choice can affect everything from how much you receive to the conditions you need to prove.
At Armstrong Law Offices, P.S. in Kent, Washington, dedicated Social Security lawyer, Attorney James Armstrong, would like to clear up the confusion. This blog highlights the differences between SSI and SSDI, explains how to qualify for each, and offers information about which one might best fit your circumstances.
Understanding these programs and consulting an experienced Social Security lawyer can help you make more confident decisions about your financial future and daily well-being.
SSI vs. SSDI
SSI (Supplemental Security Income) and SSDI (Social Security Disability Insurance) are both designed to help individuals who can’t work because of significant disabilities. However, they operate differently:
SSI
Geared toward individuals with very limited income and resources.
Provides a monthly benefit if your financial situation falls below a certain threshold, regardless of prior work history.
Funded by general tax revenues, not from the Social Security payroll tax.
SSDI
Intended for individuals who have worked and paid into the Social Security system but can no longer maintain employment due to a disability.
Requires having enough work credits, gained by paying Social Security taxes over a specific time frame.
Benefits are funded by payroll taxes that employees and employers contribute.
In Washington, claimants might apply for one program or both, depending on their income, resources, and work history.
Because each program has unique requirements, you’ll want to verify if you meet the medical criteria for disability (often referred to as the “listings”) and whether your financial or employment records point you toward one program over the other.
Eligibility Criteria
When analyzing which program is right for you, it’s important to check whether you meet each program’s eligibility rules:
SSI Eligibility
Income limits: You must have limited income or none at all. The SSA counts wages, pensions, and sometimes other household members’ income.
Resource limits: Assets like cash, real estate (other than your primary residence), investments, or vehicles might disqualify you if they surpass a certain value.
Medical disability: Just like SSDI, SSI requires proving a severe disability that impairs your ability to work at a substantial level.
Residency and citizenship: Generally, you must be a U.S. citizen or certain qualified non-citizen to qualify, though exceptions apply.
SSDI Eligibility
Work credits: You must have contributed enough to the Social Security system through employment or self-employment. Typically, a certain number of credits must have been earned within a recent period (often the past 10 years).
Medical disability: Proof of a disabling condition that significantly hinders you from working for at least 12 months or is expected to result in death.
Under retirement age: SSDI generally applies to individuals who haven’t yet reached full retirement age.
If you meet both sets of criteria—limited resources and sufficient work history—you could qualify for concurrent benefits, which means some combination of SSI and SSDI.
Concurrent cases often occur when claimants have a fairly long work record and minimal income or assets when filing.
Medical Requirements
Whether you apply for SSI or SSDI, you’ll need to prove that your disability prevents you from engaging in “substantial gainful activity” (SGA).
The SSA defines SGA as earning above a certain monthly threshold from work—if you can earn more than that level, they consider you able to engage in competitive employment.
Key Points:
You must present medical evidence, typically including physician notes, diagnostic tests, and statements about functional limitations.
The disability must have lasted (or be expected to last) at least 12 months.
Similar standards apply to mental health conditions. You need to show how symptoms disrupt your capacity to function consistently on the job.
The documentation process is crucial. Collecting consistent records from doctors, therapists, or clinics helps validate the severity and chronic nature of your condition.
Many applications are initially denied because the SSA felt the record didn’t prove the claim. Working with a Social Security lawyer can help make sure that your submissions align with SSA guidelines.
Differences in Funding and Benefit Calculation
One fundamental difference between SSI and SSDI is how benefits are determined and financed:
SSI
Funding: Comes from general tax revenues, not from Social Security trust funds.
Benefit calculation: The federal government sets a base amount known as the Federal Benefit Rate (FBR), which can be supplemented by states. Your monthly payment might be reduced if you receive other income, free room and board, or if you share living expenses.
SSDI
Funding: Drawn from Social Security payroll taxes.
Benefit calculation: Based on your earnings record. The more you’ve earned and paid into Social Security, the higher your potential monthly benefit. Some individuals receive benefits that cover an important share of lost wages.
Even though both programs share the same definition of disability, you can’t rely on the same financial means test.
This means if your spouse makes a high salary, you might still qualify for SSDI because it’s based on your own work credits, while that same scenario might disqualify you from SSI due to household income surpassing thresholds.
Impact on Health Coverage
Part of deciding which program suits you might involve how each one connects to healthcare coverage:
SSI: In many states, including Washington, SSI approval can lead to automatic eligibility for Medicaid. That coverage helps defray medical costs, particularly for long-term or chronic conditions.
SSDI: After receiving SSDI for two years, you generally become eligible for Medicare, which includes hospital (Part A) and medical insurance (Part B). Some disabled individuals must bridge the gap until Medicare starts, though they might find help via Medicaid or marketplace plans if they meet other conditions.
If you’re facing ongoing treatments or medication needs, evaluating which health coverage arrives sooner or offers the best scope can be key.
People who need immediate assistance with large medical bills sometimes weigh the possibility that SSI might grant them more immediate Medicaid coverage if they qualify financially.
Application and Review Process
Applying for SSI or SSDI typically involves multiple steps:
Initial application: You can file online, over the phone, or at a local Social Security office. You’ll need personal details, medical records, work history, and more.
Review by Disability Determination Services (DDS): In Washington, your case is typically handled by DDS staff who examine medical evidence.
Decision: If approved, you’ll start receiving benefits. If denied, you can request reconsideration and then proceed to an administrative hearing if you receive another denial.
Potential appeals: After a hearing, you might take the case to the Appeals Council or federal court if necessary.
Both SSI and SSDI follow similar procedures for determining eligibility. The difference lies in how they verify financial or work-credit components. We often guide clients through these applications, making sure forms are correctly filled out and that relevant evidence is submitted.
A Social Security lawyer like Attorney James Armstrong can ease the confusion and help you avoid pitfalls like missed deadlines or incomplete records.
Common Reasons for Denial and How to Address Them
It’s common for initial applications—both for SSI and SSDI—to be denied. This doesn’t always reflect the claimant’s ineligibility; sometimes, the issue is incomplete medical documentation or misunderstandings about the programs. Common denial reasons include:
Insufficient medical evidence: The SSA might feel the evidence doesn’t confirm the claimed severity or duration of the disability.
Earning above the threshold: If you’re performing substantial gainful activity, even part-time, it might exceed income limits for SSDI or conflict with eligibility for SSI.
Failure to follow treatment: The SSA may question your seriousness if you skip doctor visits or ignore prescribed care.
Excess resources (for SSI): A small inheritance or second vehicle might put you over the asset limit.
If you’re denied, you typically have 60 days to appeal. That appeal might involve providing additional records, clarifying how your condition meets the SSA’s definition of disability, or attending a hearing with an administrative law judge.
You should appeal if you believe your denial is unwarranted, as many claims are approved at later stages once the evidence is fully presented.
Making a Decision
If you have questions like “Do I have enough work credits?” or “Will my spouse’s income disqualify me?” or “What about my assets?” these concerns will help you decide whether to focus on SSDI or SSI.
Some individuals attempt both if they fall into potential eligibility for each. In that scenario, it’s possible to get what’s called concurrent benefits—SSDI covering a portion, plus an SSI amount if your SSDI is lower than the SSI maximum.
Factors to weigh:
Your earning history: If you’ve worked steadily for years, SSDI might be more beneficial since it can offer higher monthly payments.
Your resources: If you own a house or have savings beyond SSI’s limit, you might be ineligible for SSI unless those assets are excluded by law.
Urgency for healthcare: If you need immediate health coverage, remember that SSI recipients often get Medicaid promptly, while SSDI recipients wait two years for Medicare eligibility (with some exceptions).
Call Today
Armstrong Law Offices, P.S., led by Attorney Armstrong, guides clients in Kent, Washington, who face difficult choices between SSI and SSDI.
Serving clients throughout Kent, Seattle, Tacoma, and Renton, the Social Security law firm focuses on compiling the proper documentation, adhering to the SSA’s requirements, and, if necessary, pursuing appeals. Reach out today.